He also knows that the challenges of the journey are necessary. Rosie cotton appears at the beginning of the fellowship of the ring, working as a barmaid at the green dragon inn, where sam has developed a crush on her. The lord of the rings lord of the rings books vs movies. In this series we perform bvm or book versus movies for the. Gandalfs stand on the bridge of moria, the fellowship of the ring.
He is a main character as well as one of the main heroes in j. For example gandalf facing the necromancer was pretty epic while in the book, its nothing but a one line mention. The movie has the sense of urgency that the book doesnt. Martin revealed who he thinks would win in a fight between two of the most iconic wizards in the world.
In the book, that journey was taken for the purpose of finding and capturing golluma quest in. Tolkiens novels the hobbit and the lord of the rings. The hobbit there and back again is an absolutely wonderful classical book. Gandalf vs dumbledore death battle fanon wiki fandom. Top ten differences between the lord of the rings books. In fact, it has been made into a three part movie series, two of which have already been released. Gandalf stood in the middle of the span, leaning on the staff in his left hand, but in his other hand gl. Tom bombadil a very interesting and arguably important character completely missing from the movie. The films show the three being slaughtered rather brutally in an ambush, giving their characters a slightly less respectful end in the book. In the film, sting is gifted to bilbo by gandalf in a moment of mentorship. It may well have been the greatest movie trilogy ever, but the lord of the rings films could have.
Readers have noted in the past that book gandalf is all confidence and power as compared to his film counterpart. In the books, they demand they join frodo on the journey, and though elrond heatedly protests their presence, its gandalf who insists they be allowed to come. When it comes to comparing the movie trilogy and the original books, the overall plot structure of the movies followed faithfully to the original. The battle of the five armies inspired cinematic battle. The fellowship of the ring gandalf gives his staff and hat to pippin, bends down, and takes a large and battered book from a corpses hands. In the book, that journey was taken for the purpose of finding and capturing gollum a quest in which aragorn aided him. In tolkiens text, it is only after gandalf suggests the mines of moria that. He seems wiser, more knowledgeable, and overall more. But i feel like some points of the movie were pretty good or even superior than the book.
I decided to compare my favorite scenes from the books to the movies. If there were no template against which to compare the aragorn of the. In the book, he begins his quest at age 50, 17 years after bilbos 111th birthday and the passing of the one ring from bilbo to frodo. Tolkiens middle earth series, including the hobbit and the lord of the rings. Whether or not they have actually read harry potter or the lord of the rings, there cant. I sort of figured he downplayed gandalf so that the hobbits would shine more.
The witchking sends a magical forcefield to shatter gandalfs staff, then. Another example, though its not about magicpower, is when frodo solves the riddle of the doors into moria in the movie, and in the book its gandalf. The other two books in the series both movie and novel are. Gandalf is overall more powerful as gandalf the white. Book gandalf discussion this may be an unpopular opinion, but i prefer movie gandalf to the gandalf portrayed in the books. Im pretty sure at this point everyone is aware that the book version is far superior than the movie adaptations.
At the red carpet premiere of tolkien the biopic based on lord of the rings author j. It was only when he despaired of doing so that gandalf remembered the words of saruman about the writing on the ring, prompting him to search for the scroll of isildur, which might make the finding of gollum unnecessary. Gandalf is a very old, very wise and very powerful wizard and one of the ainur who entered the world of arda at the dawn of creation. In the book, when gandalf is facing the balrog, the balrog uses its whip to drag him down with him. In the movie, gandalfs journey included only the trip to minas tirith. Rosie does not appear until the scouring of the shire chapter of the return of the king.
Same with the hobbit movie, when bilbo is the one to keep the trolls befuddled until dawn instead of gandalf. I would argue lotr will be looked back on as a unique case of a movie actually trying to closely follow a book in plot and spirit, as compared to anything else that has ever been or. Differences between the hobbit movie and book creativity. While gandalf is talking to elrond in rivendell in the movie, a flashback shows elrond leading isildur into the fiery mountain, orodruin, and bidding him throw the. And while the movie faramir might come across as an evil doppelganger, at the heart of both the film and the. Can you tell one version of middle earth from another in our lord of the rings book vs. Gandalf the white squaring off against the witchking of angmar in the movies. Whats the difference between the lord of the rings. The scene with the barrowwights and tom bombadil is likewise missing from th.
I know the movie characters arent exact matches to their book counterparts, but its still annoying seeing these kinds of changes. An indepth analysis on the plot and character changes between the lord of the rings books and their movies for the character saruman. In the movie on the other hand they do not argue much over the way. Here are the 15 worst changes from books to movies in the lord of the rings. I changed some of the game pack files to create the unit azog and gandalf s robes colour also in vanilla submod, noldor swordsmens. Thorins adventure is only one of the many concerns of the wizard, and tolkien introduced gandalf as exactly the type of character who is involved in a lot of stories elrond, too. Frodo in the bookfrodo in the movie science fiction. Fans of epic fantasy can get their fix with either version of lord of the rings, but one thing is certain peter jacksons films differ from j. What are the major differences between lotr movies and.
Top ten differences between the hobbit book and films. The frodo in the movie is completely different from the frodo of the. Watson confirms that his character was indeed nerfed by jackson. Lord of the rings books vs movies sfphoenix oct 08, 2011 12. He was able to defeat saruman, breaking sarumans power over theoden and breaking his staff after the ents took isenguard. The fellowship of the ring was based on the first book of the lord of the rings trilogy, written by the english academic and author j. Not only is the audience a different age, but they are of a different age. In the book, aragorn wishes to go over caradhras, where gandalf argues to go through moria. He is a wizard, one of the istari order, and the leader of the fellowship of the ring. Being one of the wisest of the maiar, gandalf originally started life as a maia of irmo the dreammaster in addition to nienna the weeper, manwe the windking and vara the.
How do jacksons lord of the rings characters compare to. The book sees them charge into a battle they know they wont survive, dying as brave heroes. So much did i love this scene growing that when i saw. He persuades bilbo to go on the adventurous journey with the dwarves because he knows that bilbo, without realizing it, is an essential player in the drama that will result in the death of smaug. However, he was not allpowerful, seeing as the witchking of angmar broke gandalfs staff. The fellowship of the ring the book and the lord of the rings. Gandalf the white and saruman vs lord voldermort and death. First the book is a childrens book published in 1937, whereas the movie is a modern trilogy designed to appeal to adults of the 2010s. Ironsabbathpriest 3 kili the dwarf and tauriel the elf have a romance as a subplot in the films. He was introduced in the 1937 fantasy novel the hobbit, and became important in its sequel, the lord of the rings.
The movie could just as well have been as detached from the book as the hobbit movies were. If the scene had been filmed as it was in the book, the audience might think that it was gandalf who makes bilbo disappear not the ring. The witchking sends a magical forcefield to shatter gandalfs staff, then blast him off his. In fotr, when the fellowship is attacked by wargs, he uses magic to set trees on fire, and he holds several of the nazgul at bay by himself on weathertop. The old and wise, yet very powerful wizard rivalry comes to an astonishing end today. Gandalf cliffsnotes study guides book summaries, test. Is gandalfs origin discussed in the books but just excluded from the. In the film, this gap does not appear to exist, while there is time between the party and gandalfs reappearance, frodos youthful appearance does not support a gap of 17 years. This is by no means a complete list, but in no particular order. He is far more charismatic and has some limited foresight. In the film, he gets hit by the balrogs whip, but suddenly hangs onto the cliff before falling and facing the balrog. Gandalf, or gandalf the grey, is a wizard in the hobbit by j. An indepth analysis on the plot and character changes between the lord of the rings books and their movies for the character gandalf. In return of the king, the confrontation between gandalf and the witch king is different in the book and the movie.
I especially enjoyed his exploration of how the morality of lotr related to the christian faith, since so much of the series seems to show characters in a christian sort of good vs evil contest yet there is virtually no explicit religion in it. Even though the movie is coming to theaters on friday, its still a little hard to believe that j. Peters use of elrond and gandalf is far closer to tolkiens intentions than most people acknowledge. In the book, that journey was taken for the purpose of finding and capturing golluma quest in which aragorn aided him. Gandalf has saruman, nearly as strong as him, and other side, most of the people couldnt stun harry when he was running away from voldemart. It may well have been the greatest movie trilogy ever, but the lord of the. It is gandalfs death that precedes the event where he turns into gandalf the white, although it is not exactly a metamophosis. In the movies, however, merry and pippin are depicted as accidental warriors who join the fellowship on a whim. However, it is noteworthy some minor plot structures and characterizations were changed, and this altered the scope of the environment and feel in the movies. R tolkiens middleearth saga and peter jacksons liveaction adaptation of the books.
According to variety, star lily collins who plays tolkiens wife edith bratt in the film revealed her. Once i was done i immediately went on to rewatch peter jacksons epic adaptation of a book considered impossible to be turned into a movie. What are the major differences between lotr movies and lotr. In return of the king, the confrontation between gandalf and the.
The differences between the books and film really irk some people. Why are saruman, radagast, and galadriel in the hobbit. Tolkiens the hobbit will be made into three whole movies. The fellowship of the ring book vs movie add a difference. Faramir is evil like gandalf is green in defense of peter jacksons. Gandalfs most important role in the hobbit is as a tutelary or wisdom figure to bilbo. You shall not pass gandalf the lord of the rings lotr movie art. He is a good man who knows all life in middle earth and is openminded even to the lowliest of creatures. Tolkiens first installment of the lord of the rings. So i have been really getting into reading the lord of the rings, and i am noticing a lot of differences between the book and the movie that peter jackson directed. Gandalf pretty much figures out that bilbos ring is the one ring, but then doesnt do anything for nine years. It was only when he despaired of doing so that gandalf remembered the words of saruman about the writing on the ring, prompting him to search for the. Rowling admits to reading tolkiens famous book as a. In the past decade, the silver screen has brought some of the most epic wizards to life for millions of people throughout the world.
908 793 95 1057 182 903 446 1051 1199 530 731 115 585 15 884 85 81 1375 438 1233 187 1027 615 410 122 631 829 899 783